
Luke 2:22-28
Tradition
We all love the familiar Christmas carols, don’t we? And the children’s Nativity Play, and the Manger Scene with the Ox and Ass standing by. The Shepherds with their lamb and the Three Wise Men gathering around the manger all together.
This is our traditional crib scene, and this is how we imagine the Nativity. Over the centuries the Church has made a pretty little story out of the Nativity. There is a danger of making it seem cosy and welcoming, when in fact it was the exact opposite. The stable was cold, droughty and smelly. There was no welcome for the Son of David in David’s town - no room at the inn. And alongside the birth of the wondrous child we have such terrible events as the Slaughter of the Innocents and the Flight into Egypt.
In our Christmas services we hear parts of the Nativity story, but rarely do we hear the whole story from beginning to end. It’s all out of context – no wonder people often get confused about the story.
To those who have not grasped the whole narrative there seem to be many discrepancies. Why does Luke refer to the “manger” – presumably in a stable – while Matthew talks about the “house” where the child was? Why does Luke speak of the presentation of the child in the Temple at Jerusalem while Matthew speaks of the Holy Family fleeing for their lives to Egypt?
If we go through the story in chronological order we will see these discrepancies vanish. You see, Matthew and Luke are telling us different parts of the same story.
So let’s start at the beginning:
Preparation
Luke chapter 1 – In the days of Herod King of Judea there was a priest called Zechariah. He had a wife called Elizabeth and they were godly and righteous people. Unfortunately they had not been blessed with children. (To be a wife and childless was a disgrace in those days.) One day, when Zechariah was in the Holy Place, burning incense before the Lord, an angel appeared, to announce that Elizabeth was going to have a child. That child was to become John the Baptist, the one who would come first to announce the advent of the Messiah.
So Elizabeth conceived – even though she was well past the age of childbearing. And when Elizabeth was six months pregnant there was another angelic visitation. This time the angel Gabriel was sent to a young virgin in Nazareth called Mary who was betrothed to Joseph the carpenter. (She was a cousin of Elizabeth.)
Mary was astounded at the news that she was going to become the mother of God’s Son. but the Angel Gabriel reassured her and reminded her that with God all things are possible. Mary immediately submitted to God’s will.
I am the Lord’s servant, Mary answered. May it be to me as you have said. Then the angel left her. (Luke 1: 38)
So Mary conceived by the power of the Holy Spirit while still a virgin. She went to visit her cousin in the hill country of Judea. When Elizabeth heard the voice of Mary she felt the child in her own womb leap for joy. Mary responded with that wonderful song known as the Magnificat. After three months she returned home to Nazareth.
Joseph
Meanwhile Joseph was in a predicament. We read in Matthew how he resolved to break the betrothal quietly. He was horrified to find that his fiancee was pregnant with someone else’s child. He had not slept with her, she was a virgin and was supposed to be one until her wedding day. Joseph’s heart was broken at the thought that she had been unfaithful to him. But the Angel of the Lord appeared to him in a dream to reassure him.
Joseph son of David, do not be afraid to take Mary home as your wife, because what is conceived in her is from the Holy Spirit. ( Matthew 1:20)
So Joseph married Mary, knowing that her child was the Son of God.
Census
We go back to Luke’s Gospel for what happened next.
Caesar Augustus issued his famous decree. Like all politicians of all times he needed money – and the easiest way to get it was to raise taxes. And to raise taxes he needed to be able to check up on his subjects. So he ordered a census - everyone had to go back to their ancestral home and be enrolled on the tax register there. What chaos it caused! All the road were choked with families travelling to and fro. Joseph was of the line of King David so he had to go to Bethlehem. For Mary the journey was particularly hard and dangerous for the baby in her womb. It was 90 or so miles over rough road on foot or on donkey back and Mary was almost at full term. But Caesar Augustus took no reckoning of such things – everyone had to be enrolled, no exceptions.
When they got to their destination the town was crowded with other descendents of David who had also come to register. There was no room in the inn. And so, God’s Son was born in a stable or outhouse. Mary wrapped her child in strips of cloth and then placed him in the manger because she had no cradle for him.
Luke then tells us about the shepherds watching over their flocks who were told the glad tidings by the angel. And the choir of angels who proclaimed :
”Glory to God in the highest, and on earth peace to men on whom his favour rests.” (Luke 2:14)
The shepherds hurried down to Bethlehem and eventually found the child in the manger. They were overjoyed and praised God.
Law of Moses
After a day or so, I should imagine, Joseph and Mary found better lodging than a stable for their child. On the eighth day they took him to the local synagogue in Bethlehem to be circumcised according to the Law of Moses, and he was given the name Jesus – the name the angel had given him before he was conceived.
Now the Law of Moses also specified that 40 days after the birth of a male child that the mother should go to God’s sanctuary to undergo rituals of purification and to present her child to the Lord. So it was that Joseph and Mary travelled from Bethlehem to Jerusalem, to the Temple ( a journey of about 10 miles) with Jesus to dedicate him to the Lord. As they were bringing the baby into the Temple courts they were met by a holy prophet of God, Simeon, who took the child in his arms and blessed God
“Now, O Lord you can let your servant depart this life in peace according to your word of promise – for my eyes have seen your salvation.”
Simeon had been waiting for this moment for years. (It had been revealed to him that he would not die until he had seen the Lord’s Messiah.) Immediately he recognized this Child as the Messiah. Simeon prophesized wonderful things about the Child and so did Anna, a devout elderly lady who had spent all her time in the Temple in prayer.
Wise Men
Now you might have noticed something missing in the story so far. Where are the Three Wise Men?
Let’s put aside any idea of the wise men arriving at the stable at about the same time as the Shepherds. Also let’s put aside any idea of them being kings – it says nothing about that in Matthew. As for the tradition that they were called Balthazar, Gaspar and Melchior, and that one was a European, one an Asian and one African – all that is made up, sheer fantasy!
All Matthew tells us is that they were Magi or Wise Men. He doesn’t even tell us how many there were – although we assume there must have been three because of the three gifts. Let’s put out of our minds all traditional and legendary accretions and stick to the historical record. So where do the Wise Men fit in, if they were not in the stable?
We notice that Matthew tells us it was when Jesus was born in Bethlehem that Wise Men from the East came to Jerusalem. Some translations say after Jesus was born. And that makes sense because the wise men saw the star in their distant eastern country and that star presumably appeared on the very night Jesus was born. It could have taken them many weeks or even months to travel to Jerusalem. They may have come from Persia or from Southern Arabia.
We note that Herod was eager to know the exact time the star had appeared – he wanted to know how old the baby was. late. Later, when he was filled with anger that the Wise Men had not returned, he gave orders to slay all the baby boys under the age of two in the Bethlehem area. It thus seems likely that Jesus was more that one year old by this time – possibly getting on for two. If he was that old, then he would not have been in a stable. Joseph and Mary did not live in a stable permanently. Thus we have the explanation of Matthew’s reference to the “house” where the Child was.
Flight and return
When Herod ordered the slaughter of the children Joseph was warned in a dream by an angel and fled the country with his little family. So it was that God’s Son lives his earliest years, not in Israel, but in Egypt.
Some time later Herod died and Joseph, Mary and Jesus went back to the Holy Land. Herod’s son was in control of Judea so they didn’t settle there. Instead they went back to their old home of Nazareth in Galilee. And there it was that Jesus was brought up.
Themes
In this wonderful narrative of the infancy of Jesus we see a couple of very important themes:
God’s overruling providence
There were a number of occasions when the Child was in danger of loosing his life:
- Mary could have had a miscarriage during the arduous journey to Bethlehem.
- Jesus could have died of exposure in the street if shelter had not been provided.
- Herod’s soldiers could have killed him along with the other baby boys, But God protected his Son.
God’s concern for the outsider
In this narrative we see God’s concern for despised agricultural workers ( and shepherds really were regarded a the lowest of the low), childless women like Elizabeth ( and they really were despised), widows like Anna (who had no place in the social structure) and Gentile like the Wise Men (who would have been treated with disdain by Herod’s scribes, despite all their wisdom and wealth). And the Holy Family found refuge in the despised pagan land of Egypt – the very place where the Israelites had formally been slaves.
God chose the humble and weak people and the despised and and deprived situations to bring about his salvation. His Son came not just for the rich and powerful, the honoured and the admired. He came also for the humble, the poor, the needy, the outcast and rejected.
God’s salvation is for all people. As the angel said to the shepherds:
“Do not be afraid. I bring you good news of great joy that will be for all the people. Today in the town of David a Saviour has been born to you; he is Christ the Lord.”


